Conventional diapers make up around 7% of all landfill content in the U.S., roughly 27 billion units and 3.4 million tons of waste entering landfills every year. A single conventional diaper takes 300 to 500 years to break down, releasing microplastics throughout that process. That's the backdrop.
But the choice in front of you isn't just environmental, and it's practical, financial, and logistical. The good news is that you don't have to go all-in on one system. Most families who care about this stuff end up with a flexible approach, and that's not a compromise. It's often the smartest move.
The Case for Cloth
Cloth is the most effective way to keep diapers out of landfills. The environmental footprint is "front-loaded", in the water and energy used for washing, but managed correctly (full loads, energy-efficient machines, line drying when possible), cloth beats disposables on lifetime environmental impact by a wide margin.
The economics are also genuinely compelling. Cloth systems require an upfront investment of roughly $200–$500, but save most families between $1,000 and $2,800 over two years compared to buying disposables. If you use the same diapers for a second child, the savings increase significantly.
The Case for Eco-Disposables
Conventional disposables contain chlorine-bleached pulp, synthetic fragrances, lotions, and in many cases PFAS, the "forever chemicals" that don't break down and have been detected in umbilical cord blood in recent research. Eco-disposables address the chemistry side of this: they use plant-based fibers like bamboo or organic cotton, skip the chlorine bleach and synthetic additives, and the best brands are now specifically tested to be PFAS-free.
They're also practical in a way that cloth can't always match. Most daycares won't use cloth. Travel is far easier with disposables. Some families simply don't have the laundry setup or bandwidth for a full cloth routine. Eco-disposables are a meaningful improvement over conventional, not a consolation prize.
The Hybrid Approach
This is what most eco-minded families actually land on: cloth at home, eco-disposables for daycare, overnight, and travel. You get the bulk of the cost savings and waste reduction from cloth for the majority of changes, without forcing it into situations where it creates friction.
The smart middle ground: The GroVia Hybrid system is designed exactly for this. The same outer shell works with washable organic cotton inserts at home, or snaps in a biodegradable disposable soaker for travel and daycare. You're not managing two completely separate systems, one diaper adapts to both situations.
What Certifications to Look For
Diapering is one of the most greenwashed categories in baby products. "Natural," "eco," and "plant-based" appear on packaging with zero third-party verification behind them. These are the certifications that actually mean something:
- GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard): The standard to look for on cloth diapers. Covers the full supply chain from farm through manufacturing, requires at least 70–95% certified organic fiber content, and restricts toxic dyes and processing chemicals.
- OEKO-TEX Standard 100: Tests every component of the finished product, snaps, elastic, thread, shell material, against over 1,000 harmful substances. Applies to both cloth and disposable products. A cloth diaper with both GOTS and OEKO-TEX is the strongest signal available.
- EWG Verified: For disposables, currently the most meaningful certification. Screens for toxic chemicals well beyond standard safety requirements. Healthybaby was the first disposable diaper brand to earn it.
- MADE SAFE: Screens against 15,000+ toxins and explicitly prohibits PFAS, endocrine disruptors, and flame retardants. Most relevant for wipes and diaper creams, which go directly on skin at every change.
- Cradle to Cradle (C2C): The most advanced sustainability standard, evaluating whether a product's materials can fully re-enter natural or industrial cycles. gDiapers Disposable Inserts hold the only C2C certification in the baby diaper category, they're designed to compost safely.
For a full breakdown of how each certification works across all baby product categories, see our guide to baby product certifications.
If you've decided cloth is worth trying and want to understand what the actual day-to-day setup looks like, fabrics, washing, the diaper sprayer, skin protection, the follow-up post covers all of it: How to Actually Do Cloth Diapers at Home.
This post contains affiliate links. See our affiliate disclosure.